Thinking about buying the WD MyBook Studio 1TB?

Question

I've been looking at getting the MyBook Studio 1TB drive, but have heard very mixed reviews. I don't care if its not the fastest, I like it for the nice slim design, size, fanless-ness, and firewire 800. But some I've read some reviews that say it hangs or crashes after 2 years, etc. Anyone here have this drive? Thoughts? Alternatives?

Answer 1

I bought one of these for my Power Mac G5, running Leopard. It caused me no end of trouble -- would hang the computer at odd times, the firmware update wouldn't work. I wound up returning it; I've had a number of WD drives over the years, some of them good, some terrible. I think this is the last WD drive for me. I prefer the OWC hard drives (available from their website), which have so far proven extremely reliable.

Answer 2

WD MyBooks are the worst exterior troublesome Drives made. the flexibility buttons normally stops working after 3 to 4 months... a 300 and sixty 5 days once you're fortunate. LaCie is probable the suited exterior troublesomecontinual.

Answer 3

i do have a mybook, i have not heard that it crashes, i dont like external too much for the fact that its in the way, have you looked into an internal drive? but other then that, you can always get it replaced.