USB
2
of 4
by Bruce Tyson
Write now Print Invite a writer™ Add to Favorites RSS Feed Contact this writer
USB keyboards are the latest iteration of the PC keyboard, recently supplanting the dominance of the PS2. Some people believe that the USB keyboard is better than the older types while others may question whether the USB keyboard has any advantages at all. These questions as well as the questions arising from relevant terminology need to be answered in order to determine if the USB keyboard is at all superior to a “serial keyboard.”
Because every style of PC keyboard interface uses serial communications with the keyboard controller, they are all technically serial devices with the primary differentiation between the several types of keyboards being the connectors they use. The XT and AT style keyboards connect to the computer with a 5 pin DIN, while PS2 style keyboards connect with a 6 pin mini DIN. USB style keyboards connect with a standard USB connector.
In the vernacular, the term "serial keyboard" usually refers to an AT style keyboard, rather than to a keyboard that connects to a serial port on a computer. Although true serial keyboards do exist, they are rare in the PC world, being primarily associated with microcontrollers, TTY, and other devices. The etymology of the term is traceable to the era when the PS2 mouse was replacing the serial mouse and the PS2 keyboard was also coming into vogue. Everyone knew that the PS2 mouse was replacing the serial mouse, but people were unsure what to call the keyboard that was being replaced by the PS2 keyboard. Because of this uncertainty, an analogy developed: "A PS2 mouse is to a serial mouse as a PS2 keyboard is to a serial keyboard." This misnomer was widespread during the period, but has largely died out in conjunction with the demise of AT form factor computers.
For the purpose of this article, a "serial keyboard” is considered to be a keyboard with either an AT or PS2 connector. Here are a few criteria that help decide whether or not the USB keyboard is better than the others.
= User Interface =
Because USB keyboards function the same way as the PS2 and AT keyboards, computer users will not find any advantage to either type.
= Hot swapping =
USB keyboards are hot swappable. This means that the keyboard can be plugged in or removed at any time while the computer is running and will still work. While AT keyboards can be plugged in and removed at will most of the time, doing this sometimes causes a current spike on the motherboard, blowing the fuse that protects the keyboard circuit.
Computer technicians were among the first to learn that PS2 keyboards are not hot swappable. Plugging in a PS2 keyboard after a computer boots will not result in a functional condition: the computer has to be restarted in order to provide keyboard access. When a PS2 keyboard is disconnected while the computer is running, reconnecting it may work at times, but doing so risks damaging the computer.
= BIOS access =
Some older computers with USB ports do not recognize the USB keyboard at boot without changing a setting in the computer's BIOS. In order to change this, the user must access the BIOS (usually through pressing either the
or key at startup. Doing this requires that a PS2 keyboard be attached. Once the BIOS settings are updated, the USB keyboard will function identically as a PS2 keyboard.
= Compatibility =
When dealing with computers that have USB ports, one keyboard style will work with them all. USB keyboards permit the standardization of keyboards within an organization, eliminating the need to stock both PS2 and USB models. In the event a computer in the organization requires a PS2 keyboard, adapter modules are available that convert a PS2 keyboard socket for use with a USB keyboard.
Most new computers rely solely on the USB port for keyboard connectivity (i.e. PS2 connectors are not present), meaning that they will continue to be the preferred choice for compatibility.
= Convenience =
The primary advantage of USB keyboards is convenience.
Optional USB devices such as USB hubs can be built into USB keyboards making them more convenient in certain applications.
= Cost =
By eliminating PS2 connectors and relying solely on the USB for user interface, motherboard manufacturers have realized some cost benefits. The impact of this change on prices at the consumer level is either minimal or nonexistent.
While USB keyboards are essentially identical to their predecessors, they do offer some marginal benefits over “serial keyboards,” making them the preferred choice. However, computer users with PS2 keyboards do not have any compelling reason to change.